Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP Logo
  • Practices
  • People
  • Careers
  • News & Insights
  • Practices
  • People
  • Careers
  • News & Insights
  • Our Story
  • The Cravath System
  • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Pro Bono
  • Alumni Journal
  • 200.Cravath

Cravath’s London Office Moves to 100 Cheapside

Read More

News & Insights

Time Inc. Wins Appeal Affirming Dismissal of $1 Billion Anderson Antitrust Suit

August 06, 2018

On August 6, 2018, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled in favor of Cravath clients Time Inc. and Time Inc. Retail (formerly Time/Warner Retail Sales & Marketing, Inc.) (“TWR”), and several unaffiliated magazine publishers, national distributors and wholesalers, in affirming the summary judgment dismissal of antitrust litigation filed by Anderson News, LLC and Anderson Services, LLC (collectively, “Anderson”). Anderson, a defunct wholesaler of magazines, alleged that in January 2009 the defendants engaged in a group boycott to eliminate Anderson from the magazine industry, in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act, and destroyed its business. Anderson sought more than $1 billion in damages.

On August 2, 2010, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed Anderson’s lawsuit with prejudice, holding that the allegations were insufficient to raise any inference of a conspiracy among the defendants. The Second Circuit reversed the dismissal on April 3, 2012, and held that Anderson’s allegations were plausible at the motion to dismiss stage.

On remand, the parties completed fact and expert discovery. The District Court heard oral argument on defendants’ summary judgment motions and Daubert motions on July 22, 2015, and granted defendants’ motions for summary judgment on August 20, 2015. Anderson appealed, and Time Inc. cross‑appealed. The appeal was argued before the Second Circuit on December 2, 2016.

The Second Circuit affirmed Judge Paul A. Crotty’s August 2015 summary judgment grant, holding that “the District Court correctly ruled that Anderson has failed to offer sufficient evidence from which a reasonable jury could infer that defendants entered into such an unlawful agreement.” In an opinion by Judge Susan L. Carney, the Second Circuit held that the group boycott that Anderson alleged was implausible as an economic matter, as it would have been irrational for defendants to have wanted to reduce competition in the wholesale market. Against this backdrop, the Second Circuit held, in a lengthy, fact‑intensive opinion, that defendants’ conduct was consistent with independent action (as opposed to Anderson’s theory of a conspiracy). Anderson had announced a distribution surcharge, which defendants refused to accept, and defendants had the right to act independently in refusing to deal with Anderson and dealing instead with alternative wholesalers who offered better terms. As to Time Inc. and TWR specifically, the Second Circuit found that they made a counterproposal to Anderson, and “it seems at least equally likely that Time/TWR was genuinely interested in continuing its relationship with Anderson when it made this final counterproposal.” The Second Circuit also affirmed the grant of summary judgment on defendants’ counterclaims on the ground that defendants did not suffer an antitrust injury.

The Cravath team included partner Antony L. Ryan and associates M. Brent Byars, Daniel P. Margolskee and Lauren M. Rosenberg. The case is Anderson News, L.L.C. v. American Media, Inc., et al., No. 09-cv-2227 (S.D.N.Y.), No. 15-2714 (2d Cir.).

Related Practices & Industries

  • Litigation
  • Antitrust
  • Appellate
  • Media and Entertainment

People

Photo
Name
Antony L. Ryan
Title
Litigation
Title
Partner
Email
aryan@cravath.com
Phone
+1-212-474-1296
vCard
Download vCard

    Education

    • J.D., 1995, Harvard Law School
      magna cum laude
    • B.A., 1992, Yale College
      Phi Beta Kappa, summa cum laude

    Admitted In

    • New York
    Photo
    Name
    Lauren M. Rosenberg
    Title
    Litigation
    Title
    Partner
    Email
    lrosenberg@cravath.com
    Phone
    +1-212-474-1159
    vCard
    Download vCard

      Education

      • J.D., 2011, Columbia Law School
        Harlan Fiske Stone Scholar
      • B.A., 2008, University of Pennsylvania
        Phi Beta Kappa, summa cum laude

      Admitted In

      • New York
      Photo
      Name
      M. Brent Byars
      Title
      Litigation
      Title
      Senior Attorney
      Email
      mbyars@cravath.com
      Phone
      +1-212-474-1104
      vCard
      Download vCard

        Education

        • J.D., 2009, Harvard Law School
          cum laude
        • M.A., 2006, Emory University
        • B.A., 2004, Davidson College
          Phi Beta Kappa, magna cum laude

        Admitted In

        • New York

        Cravath Bicentennial

        Celebrating 200 years of partnership. In 2019, we celebrated our bicentennial. Our history mirrors that of our nation. Integral to our story is our culture.

        Explore

        Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP Logo
        • CONTACT US
        • OUR STORY
        • ALUMNI PORTAL
        • DISCLAIMERS & NOTICES

        Attorney Advertising. ©2025 Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP.