Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP Logo
  • Practices
  • People
  • Careers
  • News & Insights
  • Practices
  • People
  • Careers
  • News & Insights
  • Our Story
  • The Cravath System
  • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Pro Bono
  • Alumni Journal
  • 200.Cravath

Cravath’s London Office Moves to 100 Cheapside

Read More

News & Insights

Goldman Sachs Wins Complete Dismissal of Claims Related to Financing of $3 Billion Grocery Acquisition

May 06, 2020

On May 5, 2020, Justice Andrea Masley of the New York State Supreme Court’s Commercial Division dismissed claims against Cravath client Goldman Sachs, which was sued in January 2019 by its former client, United Natural Foods, Inc. (“UNFI”), the largest publicly traded distributor of natural, organic, specialty conventional grocery and non‑food products in the U.S. and Canada and a major supplier to Whole Foods. In its complaint, UNFI brought claims alleging breach of contract and fraud relating to Goldman’s handling of the syndication of a term loan that UNFI used to finance its $3 billion acquisition of SuperValu Inc., which was announced in July 2018 and closed in October 2018. UNFI sought to recover damages in excess of $230 million, representing recoupment of fees paid and other costs of syndication, as well as incremental interest costs it expects to pay over the life of the loan.

Cravath filed a motion to dismiss the case in May 2019, and argued in July 2019 that the case rested on plaintiff’s faulty assumption that but for alleged wrongdoing, the loan would have easily sold through to the market — which was unlikely at a time when both UNFI and SuperValu reported weak financial results.

In her decision, Justice Masley rejected plaintiff’s assertion that Goldman improperly withheld additional fees and interest arising from its efforts to achieve the syndication and dismissed the case in its entirety. In dismissing the breach of contract claims, the Court held that the express terms of the relevant agreements made clear that Goldman was contractually entitled to withhold the challenged financing fees, thereby rejecting UNFI’s interpretation of the relevant contract terms. Justice Masley also rejected UNFI’s claim for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing because it was duplicative of its breach of contract claim and UNFI’s position would nullify the express terms of the contract and create independent contractual obligations between the parties. Finally, the Court dismissed UNFI’s fraud claim because its allegations of justifiable reliance were “untenable” on the face of the complaint and UNFI failed to plead non‑speculative damages. Notably, in rejecting UNFI’s fraud claim, Justice Masley held that an increased risk of “net‑short debt activism” is an “impermissibly speculative” theory of harm to support UNFI’s claims.

The Cravath team was led by partners Michael A. Paskin, who argued the motion, Michael T. Reynolds and Lauren A. Moskowitz and included associates Clay H. Greenberg, John I. Karin, Margarita M. Botero, Alexander L. Mills, G. Alejandro Carvajal and Carolyn R.C. Young.

The case is United Natural Foods, Inc. v. Goldman Sachs Group, Inc., et al., Index No. 652185/2019 (Sup. Ct. May 05, 2020).

Related Practices & Industries

  • Litigation
  • General Commercial Disputes
  • M&A Litigation
  • Financial Services and Insurance

People

Photo
Name
Michael A. Paskin
Title
Litigation
Title
Partner
Email
mpaskin@cravath.com
Phone
+1-212-474-1760
vCard
Download vCard

    Education

    • J.D., 1995, Fordham University School of Law
    • B.A., 1992, University of Pennsylvania
      cum laude

    Admitted In

    • New York
    Photo
    Name
    Michael T. Reynolds
    Title
    Litigation
    Title
    Partner
    Email
    mreynolds@cravath.com
    Phone
    +1-212-474-1552
    vCard
    Download vCard

      Education

      • J.D., 1995, Yale Law School
      • M.Phil., 1991, University of Cambridge
        Keasbey Scholar
      • A.B., 1990, Dartmouth College
        Phi Beta Kappa, magna cum laude

      Admitted In

      • New York
      Photo
      Name
      Lauren A. Moskowitz
      Title
      Litigation
      Title
      Partner
      Email
      lmoskowitz@cravath.com
      Phone
      +1-212-474-1648
      vCard
      Download vCard

        Education

        • J.D., 2005, Fordham University School of Law
          magna cum laude
        • B.A., 2002, Cornell University

        Admitted In

        • New York

        Cravath Bicentennial

        Celebrating 200 years of partnership. In 2019, we celebrated our bicentennial. Our history mirrors that of our nation. Integral to our story is our culture.

        Explore

        Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP Logo
        • CONTACT US
        • OUR STORY
        • ALUMNI PORTAL
        • DISCLAIMERS & NOTICES

        Attorney Advertising. ©2025 Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP.