Keppel Offshore & Marine Ltd. Wins Summary Judgment Dismissing Fraud Claims
March 21, 2024
On March 20, 2024, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York granted summary judgment in favor of Cravath client Keppel Offshore & Marine Ltd. (“KOM”), dismissing an action alleging claims for fraud, aiding and abetting fraud and conspiracy. Plaintiffs, a set of energy and investment funds managed by EIG Management Company, LLC (collectively, “EIG”) claimed that KOM failed to disclose that it was engaged in a bribery scheme with Petróleo Brasileiro S.A. (“Petrobras”), the Brazilian oil company, and with a company under Petrobras’s control, Sete Brasil Participações, S.A. (“Sete”). According to EIG, this failure to disclose caused EIG to invest over $220 million in Sete, defrauding EIG.
The Court agreed with KOM that summary judgment was warranted on two independent bases. First, it held that there was no evidence that KOM had actual knowledge that Petrobras and Sete were defrauding EIG or concealing any corruption from EIG. Second, the Court held there was no evidence that KOM substantially assisted any fraud perpetrated on EIG. In so doing, the Court considered and rejected EIG’s arguments that KOM made fraudulent misstatements, that KOM should be held liable based on the purportedly interdependent nature of the larger bribery schemes and that particular actions taken by KOM, such as tours of its shipyards and formation of consulting agreements, constituted concealment. The court concluded no reasonable juror could find that KOM’s acts evidenced knowledge or substantial assistance of Petrobras and Sete’s scheme to defraud EIG and entered judgment in favor of KOM.
The Cravath team included partners Peter T. Barbur and Rachel G. Skaistis and associate Gaia L. Mattiace.
The case is EIG Energy Fund XIV, L.P. et al. v. Keppel Offshore & Marine, No. 18‑cv‑1047 (S.D.N.Y).
Related Practices & Industries
People
- Photo
-
-
J.D., 1987, New York University School of LawOrder of the Coif, Root-Tilden Scholar, cum laude
-
B.A., 1983, Dartmouth CollegePhi Beta Kappa, magna cum laude
- New York
Education
Admitted In
- Photo
-
-
J.D., 1997, Cornell Law Schoolcum laude
-
B.A., 1992, Yale College
- New York
Education
Admitted In
Related News & Insights
Deals & Cases
February 22, 2024
New York State Appellate Division Reverses Wrongful Criminal Conviction Resulting from Consolidated Indictments
On February 13, 2024, the New York State Appellate Division, First Department, reversed the convictions of Tommy Davis, who was simultaneously prosecuted for two unrelated incidents involving firearms. Cravath represented Mr. Davis on a pro bono basis alongside co‑counsel at the Office of the Appellate Defender.
Deals & Cases
January 29, 2024
Photographers Donald Graham and Eric McNatt Secure Favorable SDNY Judgments in Copyright Infringement Litigation Against Appropriation Artist Richard Prince and His Galleries
On January 25, 2024, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York entered judgments against appropriation artist Richard Prince and his co‑defendants Laurence Gagosian, Gagosian Gallery and Blum & Poe gallery.
Deals & Cases
January 24, 2024
Forward Air’s Amended Agreement to Acquire Omni Logistics, Resolving Previously Announced Litigation
On January 22, 2024, Forward Air Corporation (“Forward”) announced an agreement with Omni Logistics, LLC (“Omni”), a private company that is majority owned by Ridgemont Equity Partners and EVE Partners, LLC, to amend the terms of the existing merger agreement relating to their previously announced acquisition. This agreement ends the litigation between the parties, which will now be dismissed. Under the terms of the amended merger agreement, Omni shareholders will receive $20 million in cash, instead of the $150 million initially agreed, and 35% of Forward’s pro forma common equity (on a fully‑diluted, as‑converted basis), as compared to the 37.7% of Forward’s pro forma common equity (on a fully‑diluted, as‑converted basis) contemplated by the original agreement. Cravath is representing Forward in connection with the transaction and related litigation.
Deals & Cases
January 11, 2024
AerCap’s Over $1.2 Billion in Insurance Recoveries
AerCap Holdings N.V, the world’s largest commercial aircraft leasing company, which Cravath is representing in connection with U.S. sanctions and export controls matters, has secured over $1.2 billion in related insurance recoveries involving Russian airlines’ refusal to return over 100 aircraft leased from AerCap following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. In September 2023, in the first announced insurance settlement of its kind, Cravath represented AerCap in obtaining authorizations from the U.S. Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”) and the U.S. Department of Commerce’s U.S. Bureau of Industry and Security (“BIS”) for an agreement to enable payment of approximately $645 million to AerCap to resolve claims against certain Russian insurers and airlines as to a substantial number of AerCap aircraft. Cravath also represented AerCap before BIS and OFAC in connection with AerCap’s subsequent, $572 million insurance settlements with Russian insurers and airlines announced in December 2023.
